March 24, 2023
By Kevin Glew
Cooperstowners in Canada
Longtime Milwaukee Brewer Paul Molitor became a fan favourite in Toronto after the Blue Jays signed him to a three-year deal prior to the 1993 season.
What most Blue Jays fans might not know is that Molitor wasn’t the first Hall of Fame Brewer that the Blue Jays had targeted.
I recently discovered an article that Ross Newhan, the National Baseball Hall of Fame’s 2000 BBWAA Career Excellence Award winner, wrote for the Los Angeles Times on September 9, 1992 in which he indicates that the Blue Jays were one of five teams that had made a contract offer to Yount when he was a free agent after the 1989 season. Yount, of course, re-signed with Milwaukee and spent the rest of his career with the Brewers, but it’s fun to entertain the idea of Yount patrolling centre field for the Blue Jays in the early ’90s.
From the Blue Jays’ perspective, not having to face Yount would’ve been reward enough, and whatever he provided offensively and defensively would’ve been a bonus. Over the years, Yount racked up numbers against the Blue Jays (as you’ll see below) that were better than his numbers against any other team.
Born in Danville, Ill., in 1955, Yount was selected third overall in the 1973 MLB draft by the Brewers. At 18, he was an everyday shortstop in the big leagues and for two decades he was one of the most consistent and productive players in baseball. In 2,856 big league games (17th in MLB history) with the Brewers, the slim and athletic Yount collected 3,142 hits (20th all-time), 583 doubles (22nd all-time), 126 triples and 251 home runs.
After winning the American League MVP Award as a shortstop in 1982, Yount made a smooth transition to centre field in 1985 and captured another MVP Award in 1989. The versatile Brewer played in the post-season twice, leading his club to an American League pennant in 1982, but unlike Molitor, he was never on a World Series-winning club.
He retired after the 1993 season. For his efforts, he was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1999, his first year of eligibility.
His case for a plaque in Cooperstown certainly wouldn’t have been as strong without his success against the Blue Jays, who once coveted his services. Here’s a rundown of some of Yount’s accomplishments against the Blue Jays, as well as some of his other Canadian connections:
– In 204 career games against the Blue Jays, Yount hit .330, belted 25 homers and drove in 129 runs – all of these stats were the best he put up against any big league club. He also registered a higher on-base percentage (.388), slugging percentage (.513) and more triples (15) versus the Blue Jays than he did against any other franchise.
– In 74 games at Exhibition Stadium, Yount hit .313 and socked seven homers. At the SkyDome (now the Rogers Centre), he hit .279 with three home runs in 32 contests.
– Yount had 14, two-home run games during his career, the first of which came against the Blue Jays at Exhibition Stadium on September 6, 1978. In that Wednesday night contest in front of 21,390 fans, Yount belted two, two-run home runs off of right-hander Jesse Jefferson. Yount also had a double and a single to go 4-for4 with five RBIs in the Brewers’ 7-0 win. Vancouver, B.C., native and 2001 Canadian Baseball Hall of Famer Dave McKay went 1-for-3 and played second base for the Blue Jays.
– The only game that Yount ever played in Montreal was the MLB All-Star Game at Olympic Stadium on July 13, 1982. Yount was the starting shortstop and batted sixth for the American League. He went 0-for-3 with a walk. Montreal Expos ace and 2005 Canadian Baseball Hall of Famer Steve Rogers struck him out in the first inning.
– By my count, Yount had three Canadian teammates with the Brewers (player’s hometown, years played with Yount): Reggie Cleveland (Swift Current, Sask., 1979 to 1981), Kevin Reimer (Enderby, B.C., 1993) and Matt Maysey (Hamilton, Ont., 1993).
– Two Canadian pitchers allowed more than 10 hits to Yount. The Brewers star was 13-for-50 against Chatham, Ont., native Fergie Jenkins and 12-for-39 versus Kirk McCaskill (Kapuskasing, Ont.). He also faced five other Canadian hurlers (pitcher’s hometown, Yount’s stats against them): Denis Boucher (Lachine, Que., 1-for-6), Reggie Cleveland (Swift Current, Sask., 9-for-31), John Hiller (Toronto, Ont., 6-for-26), Dave Pagan (Nipawin, Sask., 0-for-5) and Paul Quantrill (Port Hope, Ont., 2-for-5).
– Yount played the last home game of his career against the Blue Jays at County Stadium in Milwaukee on September 29, 1993. The legendary centre fielder went 0-for-3 with a walk and a run, but was upstaged by Toronto native Rob Butler. Hitting leadoff for the Jays, the Canadian left fielder scored a career-best three runs and went 3-for-4 with two doubles and two walks in the Jays’ 9-6 victory. The home plate umpire that game was Montreal native and 2004 Canadian Baseball Hall of Famer, Jim McKean.
Love this story. Kudos to you Kevin for the time and research that gives added twists and interest to your blog.
Thanks for your kind words and support.
Thanks for a great story on Robin Yount.
Thanks for your continued support.
Great rundown on Robin. I didn’t know the Jays tried to get him. WOuld have meant no Devon White I assume.
Yes, I was thinking about not having Devon White as I wrote this. Thanks for your comment and support.
Great story on Robin Yount.
Thanks, Bob. I appreciate you reading this. Hope you are well.